Search Weight Loss Topics:




Mar 4

Fact/Fiction: Does eating a fried breakfast help you lose weight? – Big Issue

How to lose weight quickly Comments Off on Fact/Fiction: Does eating a fried breakfast help you lose weight? – Big Issue

We'd all start the day with a fry-up if we could get away with it, wouldn't we? So can it possibly be true that it might be the key to weight loss?

How it was told

A fry-up to start the day and helping to shed pounds sounds too good to be true. We all would if we could get away with it, right? If only.

Headlines on February 19 were an encouraging sign of that hypothetical utopia coming to pass.

The stories all stemmed from a study at the University of Lbeck in Germany published in The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism.

The Suns report, like many stories, emphasised the size of the breakfast but used a pic of a fry-up rather than centring their headline on it. They opted for: BREAK THE FAST: Eat a big breakfast to lose weight fast youll burn TWICE as many calories.

Mail Onlines effort was in a similar vein with: Eating a big breakfast instead of a large dinner could help you burn DOUBLE the amount of calories because it boosts the metabolism more. Metro, the Daily Mirror and Yahoo! also followed suit.

The Daily Stars version of the story, however, went in fully on the fry-up angle. They got stuck in with the headline: German experts say eating full English breakfasts could lead to weight loss.

Its far from the first time the tabloids have examined the merits of the fry-up and, indeed, not the first time that we have covered the full English/Scottish/Welsh (delete as appropriate) breakfast. We ran the rule over reports that exercising after a fry-up was the secret to shedding pounds in October last year.

So do these stories make a better case for sausage, eggs, bacon and the rest to be a part of your diet?

Facts. Checked

The report behind these stories makes no mention of a fried breakfast and is hardly an endorsement for Britains much-loved fry-up.

Instead, the study adds more weight to the idea that eating a big meal at the end of the day when you have less time to burn it off is not the best approach to follow.

It is true that academics did find that eating a big breakfast did burn twice the calories. The study did not measure weight loss.

The University of Lbeck-led study centred on diet-induced thermogenesis (DIT), which is a measure of how well our metabolism is working and can differ depending on meal time.

Researchers conducted a three-day laboratory study of 16 normal-weight men who ate a low-calorie breakfast and high-calorie dinner then did the reverse for a second round. The small sample size and variety should set alarm bells ringing if youre a woman reading these stories, there is little to relate to.

Nevertheless, they did find that DIT was 2.5 times higher in the morning than in the evening while the food-induced increase of blood sugar and insulin concentrations diminished after breakfast compared with dinner. Eating a low-calorie breakfast also increased appetite for sweets. The report does not state what foods were included in the meal.

DID YOU KNOW

The Big Issue is a multi award-winning magazine, edited by the British Society of Magazine Editors (BSME) current Editor of the Year.

The studys author Dr Juliane Richter said: Our results show that a meal eaten for breakfast, regardless of the amount of calories it contains, creates twice as high diet-induced thermogenesis as the same meal consumed for dinner.

This finding is significant for all people as it underlines the value of eating enough at breakfast.

She added: We recommend that patients with obesity as well as healthy people eat a large breakfast rather than a large dinner to reduce body weight and prevent metabolic diseases.

To be fair to the media outlets covering this story, the Daily Star is the main offender here. The rest do a good job of covering the report accurately on the whole, association with a fry-up aside.

The lesson here is to read coverage of scientific studies in more than one news outlet to avoid misleading takes like the Daily Stars and, sadly, not to dig into more fry-ups.

Image: Miles Cole

See the original post:
Fact/Fiction: Does eating a fried breakfast help you lose weight? - Big Issue

Related Posts

    Your Full Name

    Your Email

    Your Phone Number

    Select your age (30+ only)

    Select Your US State

    Program Choice

    Confirm over 30 years old

    Yes

    Confirm that you resident in USA

    Yes

    This is a Serious Inquiry

    Yes

    Message:



    matomo tracker